Vetted local roofers with verified reviews and licenses.
Quick Answer: Top Roofing Solutions lists 1 vetted roofing contractor in Brookhaven, NY. Compare reviews, see photos, and request free quotes from local pros rated 5 stars on average.
Below are the top-rated, vetted roofing contractors serving Brookhaven and the surrounding area. Listings are ordered by verification tier and customer rating. Every contractor includes real homeowner reviews, license details where available, and a free, no-obligation quote link.
All Island Pro Roofing & Chimney is a roofing contractor serving Brookhaven, NY. Rated 4.9 out of 5 across 180 Google reviews. Contact them through this profile for a free, no-obli...
In Brookhaven, most homeowners spend $9,000–$16,000 on a full asphalt shingle roof replacement in 2026, $300–$3,500 on a typical repair, and $14,000–$28,000 for metal roofing. Final pricing depends on roof size and pitch, material, local labor demand, and permit costs. Always compare at least three written estimates before you hire.
Get free, no-obligation quotes from local Brookhaven, NY roofing pros — usually within 24 hours.
Get Free QuotesThe highest-rated roofing contractors in Brookhaven, NY are listed below, sorted by verification tier and customer rating. Each profile shows real reviews, license details, and a free quote link so you can compare local pros side by side.
A typical 2,000 sq ft asphalt shingle roof in Brookhaven costs about $9,000–$16,000 installed in 2026, while metal roofing runs $14,000–$28,000. Local labor rates, roof pitch, and material choice all affect the final price — get at least three written quotes.
Click "Get Free Quotes" on this page or on any contractor profile, tell us about your project, and we will match you with up to three local Brookhaven roofers — usually within 24 hours, at no cost and no obligation.
Each contractor profile shows license number and insurance status when available. Always confirm a contractor is licensed in NY and request a current Certificate of Insurance before signing a contract.
Most established Brookhaven roofers offer 24–48 hour response for active leaks and emergencies, and can install an emergency tarp the same day to stop ongoing damage while a permanent repair is scheduled.